GOP Votes Give Jerry Brown Big Win on Cap-and-Trade

jerry-brownThe “shadow presidency” of California Governor Jerry Brown scored a win Monday night as eight Republican legislators crossed the political aisle and voted with most Democrats to extend a key component of the “cap-and-trade” program that has literally shifted $4.42 billion from the private sector to the government since mid-2012.

Thank you for reading this post, don't forget to subscribe!

While a lot of politicking went into rounding up the votes for the cap-and -trade extension among both political party caucuses in both chambers, it was clear that Governor Brown had enough political capital, along with a willingness to “strategically target” the spending of cap-and-trade tax dollars to woo Democrats.

So in the final days preceding a vote, much of the attention was focused on Republican legislators. Because it is a tax increase, the bill required a two-thirds vote to pass. Democrats have barely over two-thirds in either chamber and so, in theory, could have passed it without a solitary GOP vote. But Democrats were not 100% unified, and also at least one Democrat in the State Assembly was going to be absent this week on a long-planned family vacation, meaning at least one GOP vote would be needed in the lower house.

On the GOP side it was a David vs. Goliath situation, with a small coalition of small business and taxpayer advocates, as well as GOP groups like the Orange County Lincoln Club. They were out-gunned and out-spent, up against many well-heeled interests, including the California Chamber of Commerce, the California Manufacturing and Technology Association, and others. (Big businesses can handle navigating a cap-and-trade system, and largely pass along the costs to consumers. The small- and medium-sized businesses suffer the most, and of course taxpayers in general.) Those billions and billions in taxes paid to the California Air Resources Board drive up the costs of so many products — most notably gas and electricity prices: it is estimated that by the early 2020s, cape-and-trade will be adding over 70 cents to the price of a gallon of gasoline. In the end Goliath won, with more than enough Republicans voting for the extension.

Ultimately eight Republican legislators voted to extend the multi-billion dollar tax: State Senator Tom Berryhill (R-Stanislaus), and Assemblymembers Catherine Baker (R-Walnut Creek), Rocky Chavez (R-Oceanside), Jordan Cunningham (R-San Luis Obispo), Health Flora (R-Modesto), Devin Mathis (R-Visalia), Mark Steinorth (R-Rancho Cucamonga), and Chad Mayes (R-Yucca Valley), the latter being the Assembly Republican Leader.

While much attention will be paid to the “Crazy 8” (as they are already being called) Republicans who voted to extend this draconian program, it is significant to note that 34 GOP legislators voted against it, with a good number of them speaking out on the floors of their respective legislative chambers. Perhaps none spoke as eloquently as State Senator Andy Vidak (R-Hanford), who said, in part, “I represent the poorest district in the state. I cannot, in good conscience, vote for yet another bill that will raise gasoline and electricity rates on the poorest of the poor.  Let’s be honest, this is a tax — and a regressive one at that! Then where does the money go? It goes to rebates for rich folks who buy a Tesla. Billions go to the boondoggle that is high-speed rail, which is a gross polluter, now and for decades to come — again, off of the backs of the poor who currently live in energy poverty.”

Interestingly, the political win for Assembly Democrats wasn’t just in passing the cap-and-trade extension, but also the fact that so many Republicans voted for the bill that Speaker Anthony Rendon (D-Paramount) was able to let three of his targeted members, who are occupying seats the GOP would like to pick back up, either not vote at all or vote no. A big strategic blunder for Assembly Republicans.

After the vote was held, despite the fact that over two-thirds of Assembly Republicans voted against the bill, a gleeful Assembly GOP Leader Chad Mayes spoke in a press conference with Governor Jerry Brown and Democratic legislative leaders as they celebrated the passage of a package of the legislation. Mayes could hardly contain himself as he touted that with this legislation “we lowered taxes, we reduced costs, we reduced regulations – and at the same time we are going to protect our environment.”

You may ask how a two-thirds vote to raise taxes for this program for another decade could lower taxes, reduce costs and reduce regulations? Apparently Mayes and other Republicans justified their votes by imagining what it would be like if, in the absence of cap-and-trade, Democrats implemented a different and worse system. The “lowering” and “reducing” Mayes refers to are the imaginary savings achieved because the other, allegedly worse regimen of regulation, was averted.

Mayes went on to say: “We believe that markets are better than Soviet style-command and control. We believe that markets are better than the government coercing people into doing things they don’t want to do… .”

Apparently Mayes believes that when the government creates Soviet-style limits on resources but leaves people with the freedom to exist in a world of artificial scarcity on their own terms, that is not command and control.  This is analogous to having a hundred people but food for only ten, and choosing which ten get the food, versus simply putting ten meals in the room and letting the hundred people figure it out themselves.

With the cap-and-trade vote now in the rear-view mirror, it remains to see what the political fallout will be. If 2009 is any guide, which was the last time a small group of six GOP legislators crossed party lines to vote for a massive tax increase, all six legislators ended up paying a steep political price. Both legislative leaders lost their leadership posts.

Either way, the California GOP has a unique messaging problem for next year, having provided support for a multi-billion dollar carbon emissions tax.

Jon Fleischman is the Politics Editor for Breitbart California. His columns appear regularly on this page. Follow Jon on Twitter here.

This article was originally published by


  1. showandtell says

    Seems important to name the Repubs who voted yes, doesn’t it?
    EIGHT Republicans voted for it
    The only Repub in SENATE to vote for it was Berryhill
    Repubs in the ASSEMBLY who voted for it:
    Catharine Baker
    Rocky Chavez
    Jordan Cunningham
    Heath Flora
    Devon Mathis
    Chad Mayes
    Marc Steinorth

  2. Randolph Frodsham says

    It is an insult to refer to any RINOs who voted FOR this bill as Republicans. The title “RINO” must be adopted universally so these can be targeted for removal. It is better that a real Democrat occupy the seat than an insult to conservative thinking be there.

  3. Freedome Fighter says

    One more time, Brown shows he doesn’t give a rat’s patootie about the taxpayers of this state. Kids will be reading about the legend of how great California ONCE was. What a cryin’ shame!

  4. The only thing I can think of that made this vote for it $$$$$$$$$$$$$$ Moonbean and the demorats are communist that want to destroy the US Now we have RINO’s to join the list. So is there really any difference in the parties?

  5. askeptic says

    Eight CA GOP pols join Bob Dole in the “Tax Collector for the Welfare State Club”.

  6. Thankfully escrow closes on a home in Arizona on August 8th and we’ll be completely out of the state by year end. We will not be here when it collapses.

  7. Brown will be know as the Governor that was responsible for the Fall of the State of California. This is the governor that collaborated with the marxist barbarians to kill California by taxation.

  8. Jim Carr says

    Thanks for listing these RINOs….hope they are all replaced.

  9. Really??? says

    Republicans are supposed to stand for things with more backbone.

    The actions to back this stupidity is immoral and most certainly un-just. It is bad science and is the money scheme to take more money and force you to be dependent on government.

  10. retiredxlr8r says

    Comrade Brown wins another round with the support of the Brown Shirts in the legislature.
    Welcome to the Socialist (Communist) State of California.
    If the citizens of California don’t wake up soon, they will deserve everything they get which won’t be much because the State is going to take it all and they will do so without remorse.
    California Democrats are useless and that includes their voters.
    The Exodus will continue and increase, there is no alternative!
    Tyranny is alive and well in California.

  11. TheRandyGuy says

    Another example opt why I don’t vote for R’s – they are simply D’s in disguise. CA is lost.

  12. TheRandyGuy says

    Another example of
    why I don’t vote for R’s – they are simply D’s in disguise. CA is lost.

  13. Andrew Kessel says

    As a registered Republican in CA, who obeys the laws and pays my taxes (not asking for one dime from CA ever) this is my message from CA…. You are a chump. We will tax you into oblivion. Freeloader.
    I’m pissed. It seems the only solution left is to break away and start over. It seems the State of Jefferson is the only solution for my area. Whatever. I am done with the Cannellas, the Changs, the Berryhills, the Bakers, etc. Just change to Democrat and get on with it. I am not represented anymore.

  14. dntgiveup says

    Vote these nuts out of office who the hell needs these rinos!!!

  15. All of this “global warming” stuff is BS. Read “CO2 Is Innocent” at and do the demo-experiment and you can prove to yourself.

    Google “Two Minute Conservative” for more.

  16. I am appalled that this passed, and that eight Republicans in the Assembly voted for this!! We need to show them that there is a price to pay for this lunacy. Let’s not just complain, people. Let’s DO SOMETHING about this!! First step: run other Republicans against them in their next primary battle. I’ll send a contribution.

Leave a Reply to askeptic Cancel reply